I think this book is definitely not one of his strongest, but it still has greatness. It is sort of like his alter-ego Kilgore Trout's books in a way, in that there is a very serious point to be made in it, but once that is done you're left looking at a rather strange shell. I think the central point to Rosewater and the eponymous Eliot is that with all else gone, humans need to be able to find satisfaction in just being. Eliot tries to give unconditional love to those poor souls around him, regardless if they are able to do any meaningful work, which goes quite against his billionaire father's ethics. In doing this, however, he becomes quite pitiable, and well, because I'm not the writer that Vonnegut is, I have to say he forgets to love himself. I loved the deus ex machina that comes at the end with Trout explaining to Eliot that he's quite alright, and basically spelling out the meaning for the reader. Somehow it works.
Something fascinating about the way the novel was structured was that in the beginning, I was quite onboard with Eliot in thinking that everyone deserves to be loved even if they useless. Most authors would posit that and not put it into practice. Vonnegut, however, really hit me over the head with these useless characters, and I started to get angry near the end when he kept introducing Eliot's clients of uselessness. One after another they came, and I wanted to yell, where is this going? Then I realized that Vonnegut was really challenging the reader to love those that society has deemed unfruitful. Brilliant work.
I was going to tie in the inheritance plot of the book into my writing sample below but that's not really what I want to talk about, and I don't mean to waste anyone's time writing something elegant and meaningless.
So here's something that I have written:
Ancestor
--
"UltraLife cameras are on the cutting edge of today's scientific breakthroughs! From hundreds of miles beneath the seas, to exploring the stars, UltraLife is dedicated to supporting our men and women on the frontier of discovery. We've spent years developing longer lasting batteries and components that you NEVER have to change. Just ask a scientist near you; if they can trust it, you can too!"
--Syndicated radio ad, rates 8k/min, 0100 spot
--
As the eyes of the world faded from their monitor, Sera untied her hair and sank into the cushions of her armchair. Wilson laid down the potted tomato stalk onto the shelf, being careful not to entangle himself in the hydroponics. He produced a colorful bag of chips from the side compartment.
They both shared a smile, self-conscious of the fact that it was one of the few lately that hadn't been broadcast around the world. "This wouldn't make for much of a discussion for Middlebrook elementary, though, would it?" Wil said, pointing to the bag of barbecue rib chips floating a few inches above his lap.
"No, but its funny to think that it's paying our bills, don't you think?"
Wil frowned like he always did, analyzing and overthinking. "No, not really. What do you mean?"
It got tiring, Sera thought. Having just enough room to move your arms and legs, being on conference calls with half the planet watching for 8 hours each day, and then her having to explain her own idle chatter to her partner. That we have to teach beginner courses in agriculture instead of tending to our shuttle. Is that what you signed on for? she almost clarified.
But she caught herself. "Not too long ago the only affordable journey to Mars would have involved slapping a corporate logo on our rover," she said, knowing her inner thoughts would drive her crazy if she let them. "We have it good, I guess. It's just funny. Not two decades ago the tabloids would have had starlets on the covers instead of spacecrews."
"Oh. I guess I just never paid much attention to that culture. This is all I ever wanted to do. Or maybe teach science," Wil said.
"Then I guess you're pretty well set," Sera said. The man seemed more suited to living in space than he did on Earth, even having aced all the exams. As soon as they broke atmosphere, the snoring she had grown so used to in training had disappeared. He passed the chips to Sera, half-empty, but she held her hand up. Rolling it up, he pushed himself off his seat and spiralled behind her to the back of the cabin. The bag floated slowly towards her until she pushed it away.
"I think growing up during the Second Space Race had a lot to do with it. Those bootstrap guys at NASA, man, I must have wrote to them every month for three years. And when they announced the Mendel rocket, I got the whole school involved trying to get them to come."
She'd heard the story before, and maybe it was her tiredness, or maybe just wanting to have something new to talk about for once, but she opened her mouth before she heard the rest of it again. "Did I ever tell you? He came to our school. Last stop before the mission, actually."
There was a loud bang, and Sera looked back to see that he had struck his head while doing his zero-G aerobics. Wil didn't even seem to notice the welt on his head. "You talked to Clifton?" he asked, his eyes wide.
She turned her head back to the monitors and dials they only ever touched to stay in practice. Idly she rubbed the dust off the Bathroom Heat Control. "You see those pictures and videos of him, but he was much more impressive in person. He tried his best to be approachable, I know now, but we were all so intimidated at the time. I remember him like he had this glow around him." She paused, realizing Wil had come down to sit next to her since she was talking so quietly. There was nothing but her voice. "I had the last question too. I almost didn't ask it, but the teacher insisted. I had done my last three class projects on Mars," she said. They both laughed, because Wil had been obsessed with Mars too.
"My god, Sera with the last question. Why isn't this in all the tabloids? What did you ask?"
"Nobody remembers it, I guess. And I've never brought it up, well," she said, rubbing her arm, "because it's a bit embarassing. But, okay. I was panicking and I had a hundred better questions but I forgot them all, and I'm this little pencil-necked girl with braces, you see. So I ask him, and I have this photographic memory of this moment, him looking down at me. I ask him 'Why has it taken us until now to go to Mars?'"
She didn't expect a gut-wrenching laugh from Wil, but the half-smirk still hurt, like he was pitying her instead of finding it funny. But she went on.
"He could have written it off, but I'll never forget what he said. He called me by my name, and said, 'We have the technology, we have the money and materials. Mars might only be a footnote in our history if we want it to be. What we need is more people like yourself. People who care and who have a sense of adventure, to advance our knowledge of the universe. People who want more.' I'll never forget that."
Wil thought for a moment in the silence. "He was a great man, but also a good one. He must have been, to make you feel welcome like that."
She dimmed the lights of the cabin, and they moved towards their bunks. "I had this irrational guilt, though, as if I thought I was the last person he ever spoke to. It didn't make a lot of sense, but I couldn't get it out of my head. Like my question implied some sort of fault with him, or with the program. And I couldn't get it out of my head, that maybe he... that my question was his last thought, as the lander went down."
"Nothing good comes of thinking like that. There wasn't any good footage, but from what the camera on the orbiter saw, those shields burnt up immediately," Wil said, cracking his back. "Now we've got backups, and backups of backups, and not saying we can slack off, but that won't happen to us. We're ready now, and this is just the start."
"Shit, I'm sorry, I don't mean to make you nervous," Wil said in the darkness. "Sera?"
"Check one," she said.
The air filter whirred.
"Check two," he said.
"All clear," said the dispatcher. "Prepare for landing procedure at zero-hundred."
She stared at the corn stalk in the dimness as sleep came to her. The plant Clifton had brought to her class had outlived him. In her dreams, the last words spoken aboard the Mendel came to her again, as clear as ever, "I see--" the last words before the shock of a whole era.
--
The camera's light went from green to red, and they wasted no time putting the golfing equipment away. "Crazy to think we actually practiced in a simulator for this, and in the end its not all that different, right? Just got to get the swing down," Wil said, as they packed away the clubs and astroturf. "Right?" he asked. They had everything tied down in the rover, and Wil sank into a sullen silence as he commandeered from his wheel. Dispatch's chime came through their speaker and reminded them of their mission, but it could have been automated for all she knew, they'd heard the same thing so many times. Once it ended they drove on for a long time, only speaking which dispatch needed their routine updates.
"Look, I'm not upset at you or anything. We're telling the public this is our rest time, right? But we're still out here on the red planet kicking up dust after twenty hours, so pardon me if I'm a little irritable. Really, it's nothing you can help."
"Okay. Sorry," he said, and adjusted his helmet. "What do you think we're going to find?"
"Nothing, I hope." She noticed their path was taking them higher and higher up towards a plateau, but it was nothing that deviated from their route.
"Just makes me feel like a bit like a pawn, you know? I had to keep hoping those kids wouldn't ask me a question I had to lie about. Thank god they didn't. How did you feel when you learned Clifton's team didn't go down near the eye of the storm? That really threw-"
"Stop!" she yelled, and pressed the emergency brake behind her wheel. The rover skidded to a halt, pounding them with stones and covering them in a red mist of dirt. She had several voices from Dispatch inquiring just what the hell had happened. She switched her communications off as Wil tried to make sense of what she was doing and appease Dispatch. "Don't get out of the rover," she said to him.
Despite his protests, she went to the front of the rover, and leaned down. When the dust finally cleared, Wil saw the same thing she had. A dessicated corn husk, blowing through the wind like a tumbleweed. "Clifton's team," he said, "Mendel." He switched off his communications as well, and they looked about themselves.
The lander was nowhere to be seen, but to their left there was a recession in the wall.
She turned her communications back on. "Markings on a wall, like they've been chipped away by tools," she said. "We're going to investigate," she said, and switched it back off.
Inside the cave was completely dark, and they turned on their suit lights. The cave lit up in an instant. She nearly tripped on an old generator, and she followed it up to what it powered. Above them hung several heat lamps, enough to have lit the whole cave. That was not what took the breath from Sera.
Most of the cave was taken up by crops. It was all brown and dead, but they seemed animated by a dull breeze. They could tell which plant was which by the stakes planted next to each. Corn, tomatoes, beans, it had all grown here, but when the heat lamps went dark, it had all turned dead, dead, dead. In the corner nearest them, Sera kneeled and sifted through a bag of seeds. Wil appeared at her shoulder, pointed to the far side of the cave.
They entered the makeshift barracks, the red blinking lights of their cameras giving strange illumination to the ruin, much too late.
























